Optometric Management Tip # 230   -   Wednesday, June 14, 2006
Avoiding Refunds on PAL Non-adapts

Iím generally not in favor of using many disclaimer forms for patients to sign, but sometimes they can serve a good purpose. Sometimes called an Informed Consent, these written documents provide important information to patients about services or products and they can prevent misunderstandings about office policies. One of the criteria I use to determine if we should adopt a signature form is the frequency of misunderstandings. I am mindful that patients generally dislike legal forms that they are asked to sign and that too many of these can create a negative impression.

One event that has happened often enough in my practice is when a patient canít adapt to progressive addition lenses, the job is remade into a flat-top bifocal, and the patient requests a refund of the difference in the fees. Most wholesale labs will cover the cost of the second pair of lenses at no charge, but the first pair is discarded and the cost for the progressive lenses remains. Our office policy mirrors that lab policy: we remake Rxs that are not adapted to, but no refund is provided. With the difference in my fees between progressives and flat tops at over $100, I feel this policy should be explained in advance.

Here are a few points we have learned about progressive lens educational forms. Here is the form I developed for my practice. Feel free to adapt it to your needs as you see fit.



All progressive addition lenses (also called invisible or no-line multifocals) have a slight optical distortion in the outer portions of the lens, which can make some objects appear bowed or curved, or can cause a feeling of motion when the head is turned. The reading zone in progressive lenses is wide enough for most purposes, but it may be narrower than some other bifocal styles. These factors are usually minor and disappear with wear. The advantages of this lens generally outweigh the problems and the success rate is over 95%. While most people are not bothered by these characteristics, some will find it unacceptable even after a one-week adaptation period.

If you cannot adapt to progressive addition lenses, we will make new lenses in any other design that you wish at no charge, within 30 days of dispensing. Since the original lenses were a custom prescription item which must be discarded, there are no refunds of the difference in cost if the remake pair is of lesser value.

I have read and understand this policy.

Patient's initials ________ Date _________ Technician ____________________


Best wishes for continued success,

Neil B. Gailmard, OD, MBA, FAAO
Chief Optometric Editor, Optometric Management